How qualified I am to comment on this issue?:-
1. Citizen of India
2. Have grown up seeing trees making space for NCR (especially Gurgaon, Dharuhera, Manesar, Sidhrawali)
3. Have enjoyed the bagiyaa and jungles of my village in Ayodhya, which are still the same.
Points against my qualification:-
1. I do not live in Mumbai.
2. I am not the immediate loser or gainer of the cutting of Aarey forests.
*****
Once upon a time In Dharuhera (Haryana), Aravali ranges used to be visible from my terrace. Every evening my favourite time was to enjoy the trance created by those ranges, a far stood Mohan baba ka mandir and the darkening of trees under the twilight. Slowly as I grew up, my city also grew up. More Industries came and the horizon started diluting slowly. It finally became invisible. The visual treat of the trees retreated with the temple, with the ranges and with the trance. Then we migrated to Gurgaon, now only Moon and Sky are natural companions.
Do I regret? A big NO! Is there a sense of loss? - Certainly! A void of knowing I will not be able to see those horizons, as they do not exist anymore. I cannot return to that childhood solitude ever. That poetic soiree with my favourite Horizon has gone!
Nevertheless, the kind of evolution of a place I have seen was a phenomenon. The massive amount of wealth creation changed the lives of many families and their generations. Prosperity brings the best brand of the hope. A childhood full of success stories. I internalized the vibes of the making of the Gurgaon (the Millennium city). The multiplier effect on dreams and aspirations of the masses has taught me economics better than my textbooks.
So, is my love for trees less than your love for trees? I do not know about this... My love for many things is always under my control even if it feels like obsession to me. So may be even in this I might sound cold towards the cutting of trees when it comes to Infrastructure. However, I write being the citizen of this country for what I know is correct.
Q. Will I ever join a protest against cutting of trees for metro if HC of the state has approved it? A big NO
Q. Will I ever join any drive to plant more and more trees? Yes (Shouting from the rooftop kind of)
(Anyways! My personal silent protests are regarding many issues since I have started understanding the hypocrite nature of human beings. Being human is being a hypocrite!)
Now! Coming to Aarey Forests!
Mumbai is not an ordinary city. It is the financial capital of India. It deserved metro decades ago. Well-planned deforestation is required for such projects and trees can be planted in more and more numbers at other places.
Civilizations are built upon jungles, we can never payback our trees but we can certainly increase their numbers. Delhi Metro has immensely contributed in diluting the traffic-generated pollution in the NCR region. It has added time and space to Delhi. It has increased the holding capacity of the city.
Mumbai needs metro (As per my honest common sense). If HC has approved it, at least let us trust our judiciary; let us plant more trees somewhere else.
I accept I am dishonest towards my love for my best memories which have always been under nature (be it trees be it rain). Nevertheless, what needs to be done has to be done and will be done. This will never be 100 percent correct like many things and like many decisions. We have come far away from the possibility of win - win situations. There will be heart breaking trade-offs, in fact there always have been. However, there is much of economics beyond the trade-offs, beyond the Pareto optimality matrix. The economics of human consciousness and transition of the same. This juggling with all the forces of nature, construction, destruction, inertia and acceleration can be understood if one can simply understand that mechanism of breathing. The answer is in the pause between inhaling and exhaling. In that pause we build civilizations, metros, furniture, papers or etc.